Showing posts with label alternator. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alternator. Show all posts

Sunday, July 21, 2024

2023: Electrical Issues Persist

One of LIfe's Big Mysteries

On the journey along the US ICW and through the Caribbean we found that, and particularly when motoring, the batteries did not charge very well.  We might be motoring for six or seven hours yet, at the end of the day, the batteries had not charged much.  When stationary and the sun is shining the batteries would show a fairly healthy state of charge, but if not sunny, we would have to run the gas generator.  So I sought the assistance of Mike in St Marten to, not only sort out the AIS/Navionics set up but to also trouble shoot the whole electric charging system.

Keep in mind that, when stationary, the fridge and freezer were operating 24 hr each day drawing, on average, about 5 amp hours.  When sailing/motoring there is an additional draw from the auto pilot, say 3-4 amps depending on conditions.  And at night time of course there is no charge coming into the batteries.

So, Mike started with the solar panels.  We found on a mid sunny day that the solar panels were producing around 16 volts each (should be 18-19 volts but still reasonable).  Three, spread over the arch, are hooked up in parallel.  On checking the wiring we found that there were two places along the cable where it had noticeably overheated.  Mike fixed this by cutting out about a metre of this cable and joining another (thicker) wire to the original cable to fill the gap.  Worked much better.

Next we checked the charge when the motor was running and the alternator was doing its thing.  The smart regulator showed that it was all okey on startup and shortly thereafter, so all seemed good.  We even tried the spare smart regulator to see if that improved things – according to Mike it did so I left it connected.

All seemed to be looking good and we departed St Marten and headed south/east.  Along the way ie a day or so later and while motoring between Nevis and Deshaies (pronounced day eh), Guadeloupe, I found the regulator had stopped working ie no lights showing at all.  I did not stop as the engine continued to run normally and we were pushed for time, plus the seas were quite lumpy and uncomfortable.  We stayed for a few days on a mooring in Deshaies, so I tried to fix the problem with the regulator, but without success.  I even tried to wire the internal regulator of the alternator (which is available for this alternator) but that did not seem to work either.

We pushed on to Pointe-à-Pitre, Guadeloupe where we were to be joined by my mate, Lawrie, from Oz, who just happened to be an electrician, computer nerd and self-made vehicle mechanic.  He wanted some work to do but he walked into a bit more than I think he anticipated and indeed was challenged.

After many hours of checking this and that, wires, terminals, multimeter checks, on engine, alternator, regulator, owner manual(s), fatigue, blah blah blah almost by accident, Lawrie found that the power cable for the regulator was loose at the fuse.  He found this by jiggling the wire while the motor was running and the regulator was not showing any lights.  Simple, and with a bit of fiddling of the fuse fitting so that it was much more secure, it has not failed since.

Next problem.  When running the engine our battery monitor would show 20 amps, say, belting into the batteries for about one minute and then followed 3-4 minutes of negative power flow ie no positive amps and just a few amps leaving the batteries.  This had us completely baffled and much checking (as above) followed.  Finally, Lawrie jiggled the excite wire and the AC tachometer wire, which were part of a plug assembly joining the regulator with the alternator, and low and behold the problem became obvious.  The plug assembly was intermittently connecting/disconnecting.  The fittings were made more secure and so power to the batteries became consistent ie starting with 20 amps and lowering as the batteries became more charged but always positive current flow into the batteries.  Much joy and celebrations followed, the engine charging problems, when the engine was running, appeared to be finally resolved.

That is, until we cruised into Carriacou, Grenada from Mayreau.  As we came to anchor, there was a nasty smell of burning electrical insulation/cable coming from below.  It sort of went away when we turned off the motor and could find nothing obvious, but the smell lingered. 

A couple of days later, when we motored into Clarke Courts Bay, on the southern side of Grenada, we checked more widely and thoroughly, and found the alternator wires, where the excite and tacho wire entered the alternator, had melted.  Lawrie then resurrected the old alternator, fitted it, and then everything worked (again).  (Clearly we've been keeping our visiting crew very, very busy this year!)

So, in September (2023) and on the hard in Power Baats Yard in  Trinidad, the ‘new’ alternator is in the repair shop and the old one is still fitted to the engine.  When the ‘new’ one comes back, assuming it is healthy, we will refit it and the old one will go back to being my trusty spare.

What caused the overheating/meltdown on the alternator remains a mystery!


Monday, February 18, 2019

2017 & 2018: Bless Those Batteries

Ongoing Saga: #11

Solar Panel Regulator, New House Batteries and New Smart Regulator for Alternator.

This was the beginning of a long drawn out and rather expensive saga over a period of nine months.  Sopromar Boatyard in Portugal were asked if they could come up with some charging solution for my three sets of batteries while I was away back home – a single 12 volt starting battery, four 6 volt house batteries and 2 bow thruster batteries.  In the numerous exchange of emails over several months the result was that there wasn’t a solution.  Meanwhile the regulator for the solar panels had malfunctioned, needed replacing and that subsequently the four house batteries had gone flat and needed to be replaced, which they duly did ie solar regulator and batteries.  The old batteries were almost 10 years old – a ‘Trojan’ performance, so probably time for new ones.

At the same time I also had the alternator checked out and we identified that we needed a new regulator for it, which I purchased separately and brought back over with me when I returned to the boat in mid Aug17.  Sopromar fitted the new regulator, tested it and that was that.  Or so we thought.

The bow thruster batteries are AGM and so had held up fairly well and the techo had wired them up somehow so that they received a trickle charge of some sort from the solar panels and didn’t flatten.  AGM batteries can fairly happily sit for up to around six months without any charging and not suffer I’m reliably informed.  

Anyway, to cut a long story short the new regulator was not wired correctly and so the batteries steadily drained once we got underway, except for some charge from the solar panels (which only charge the house batteries and starter battery).  The bow thruster battery charging only occurs when running the motor/alternator.  To add to this mix, we had a generator that didn’t work.

Our batteries were recharged on shore power whilst ever we were in marinas at Lagos, Madeira, Canary Islands and then Cape Verde Islands.  In between were relatively short trips so I wasn’t too concerned as the solar panels did their thing outstandingly and I rarely used the bow thruster.  It was on the 16 day Atlantic crossing that I became fully aware of the charging problem as the starter battery voltage in particular dropped significantly, although I was always able to start the engine when I had to.  

On arrival in Antigua (where we anchored) I had an electrician look at the charging system and he thought it was all okey, particularly when his meter showed 12.6 volts (not the 13 – 14 volts necessary) and he thought the regulator was doing what it should.  He also condemned the house batteries as needing replacement even though they were less than 12 months old.  

No point arguing, so we pushed onto Sint Maarten, initially on anchor but later on shore power at FKG Rigging, where I was able to charge the batteries using shore power.  I also had the house batteries charged and tested at Budget Marine where they were announced as being in good condition.


Next stop was Turks Caicos (shore power in the marina) where another electrician, a friendly French Canadian, made a valiant effort to identify the problem of a very low charge and suggested that the regulator was faulty, only achieving ‘float’ voltage instead of starting with ‘bulk’ and moving through ‘absorption’ and then onto ‘float’.  He also had access to the regulator manual and spoke to the manufacturers but thought it was wired correctly.

We entered the US at West Palm Beach, Florida and then proceeded north along the Intracoastal Waterway anchoring most nights - happily for as long as we had sunny weather.  Unfortunately, further problems were experienced when we had a succession of overcast days and the batteries received very little solar power.   We then experienced some difficulty when anchoring off New Smyrna Beach using the electric anchor winch.  The starter battery was quite sick by now so, with Daytona in our sights, we kept the engine running all night, pulled the anchor up by hand the next morning (thankfully it was clean sand), and made for Daytona Beach.

We berthed in Halifax Harbour Marina (great people and very friendly fellow boaties).  I tried to charge the starter battery using shore power but it would not hold a decent  charge so I had to purchase a new one.  I also consulted with a trusted electrician who had done some work on the boat about 9 years previously after the mast had been hit by lightning.  He is semi-retired now and advised that I should do it myself – every good captain should know how to set up a regulator he said - so read the manual at least three times – and then do what you need to.   I followed his sound advice and found that the regulator was wrongly wired, wired it correctly myself, and now all batteries are charging pretty efficiently, although I sometimes wonder if the starter battery should not be getting a bit more charge.

In summary, three electricians couldn’t get it right, but the fourth electrician gave me best support of all – do it yourself.  Lesson learned, big time.